Guides & tier listsScanHow we ratePricingMy purchasesFree guide

How we rate products

One method for every guide: read the ingredient list, apply the same written rules to every product, and show the source.

  1. We pick a product type and the brands shoppers in the US are likely to see on the shelf.
  2. We cite one ingredient list per product: a USDA FoodData Central entry, or the manufacturer's or retailer's own product page. Each product links to that source and shows the date we read it.
  3. We write the rules before ranking. Each guide prints its rules in order (for example, "the list names a numbered color"). The first rule that matches a product decides its tier.
  4. Tiers S to F. S names none of the guide's flagged entries; F names an entry its SKIP rule covers. In the PDF, tiers S and A are marked BUY, tiers B, C and D are marked CHECK, and tier F is marked SKIP.
  5. Counts come from a script, not by hand: the number of comma-separated entries on the cited list is computed the same way on the site, in the PDF and in the video.

What a tier does not mean

A tier is our opinion about what the cited list names, under the rules printed in that guide. It says nothing about taste, price, nutrition or safety, and nothing about any company's intentions. Lists change and can be older than the package on the shelf, so always read your own label. Not medical advice; not affiliated with any brand.

See the tier lists Get the free guide