Guides & tier listsScanHow we ratePricingMy purchasesFree guide

Vanilla Extract: the full list

10 products, sorted into tiers S to F by the ingredient line we cite for each one. Checked Nov 17, 2026. Sources: the manufacturer or retailer pages linked on each product.

Our opinion, based on the ingredient lists we cite; the same rules were applied to every product. Lists can be older than the package on the shelf, so always read your own label.

Tier mix

Verdicts in the PDF guide

Tiers S and A: the cited list names vanilla bean extractives, water and alcohol, and at most an added sugar. Tier C: the cited list names other flavors or a color next to the vanilla. Read the label on the bottle you buy. Tier F: the cited list names vanillin or an artificial flavor.

Tier list

Tap a product to jump to its bar and its ingredient list.

S6
A1
B0
none in this guide
C1
D0
none in this guide
F2

Entries on the cited line

Comma-separated entries on the cited ingredient line, as counted by our script (same count used in the video). A longer line is not a verdict by itself.

S 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Vanilla Extract3
S Frontier Co-op Pure Vanilla Extract, Organic3
S Good & Gather Pure Vanilla Extract2
S McCormick Pure Vanilla Extract1
S Simply Organic Pure Madagascar Vanilla Extract2
S Spice Islands Pure Vanilla Extract3
A Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla Extract4
C Watkins Original Gourmet Baking Vanilla7
F McCormick Premium Vanilla Flavor7
F Watkins Clear Vanilla Flavor5

Compare two labels side by side

Entries printed on both lines are marked "shared". The text is the ingredient list from the cited source, as parsed by our script.

All products

ProductTierEntriesRuleSource
365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Vanilla ExtractS3R4wholefoodsmarket.com · Nov 17, 2026
Frontier Co-op Pure Vanilla Extract, OrganicS3R4frontiercoop.com · Nov 17, 2026
Good & Gather Pure Vanilla ExtractS2R4target.com · Nov 17, 2026
McCormick Pure Vanilla ExtractS1R4mccormick.com · Nov 17, 2026
Simply Organic Pure Madagascar Vanilla ExtractS2R4simplyorganic.com · Nov 17, 2026
Spice Islands Pure Vanilla ExtractS3R4spiceislands.com · Nov 17, 2026
Nielsen-Massey Madagascar Bourbon Pure Vanilla ExtractA4R3nielsenmassey.com · Nov 17, 2026
Watkins Original Gourmet Baking VanillaC7R2watkins1868.com · Nov 17, 2026
McCormick Premium Vanilla FlavorF7R1mccormick.com · Nov 17, 2026
Watkins Clear Vanilla FlavorF5R1watkins1868.com · Nov 17, 2026

How tiers are decided

The same rules, in this order, for every product in this guide. The first rule that matches decides the tier.

  1. F R1. The cited list names vanillin or an artificial flavor.
  2. C R2. The cited list names other flavors (natural flavors or flavorings) or a color (and none of the above).
  3. A R3. The cited list names an added sugar or syrup (and none of the above).
  4. S R4. The cited list names only vanilla bean extractives, water and alcohol.
Want the verdicts, the label text and the sources for every product?

The PDF guide has them, plus a store checklist.

Buy this guide · $4.99

Our opinion, based on the ingredient lists we cite; the same rules were applied to every product. Lists can be older than the package on the shelf, so always read your own label. Sources: the manufacturer or retailer pages linked on each product.

More tier lists

See all 40 guides