Guides & tier listsScanHow we ratePricingMy purchasesFree guide

Butter: the full list

11 products, sorted into tiers S to F by the ingredient line we cite for each one. Checked Nov 12, 2026. Data: USDA FoodData Central.

Our opinion, based on the ingredient lists we cite; the same rules were applied to every product. Lists can be older than the package on the shelf, so always read your own label.

Tier mix

Verdicts in the PDF guide

Tier S: the cited line names none of the entries in the rules. Tier D: the cited line names natural flavor or natural flavoring. Read the label on the product you buy. Tier F: the cited line names an oil (canola, soybean, palm, avocado or an oil blend).

Tier list

Tap a product to jump to its bar and its ingredient list.

S6
A0
none in this guide
B0
none in this guide
C0
none in this guide
D2
F3

Entries on the cited line

Comma-separated entries on the cited ingredient line, as counted by our script (same count used in the video). A longer line is not a verdict by itself.

S Challenge Salted Butter3
S Good & Gather Salted Butter2
S Kerrygold Unsalted Butter Sticks3
S Organic Valley Organic Salted Butter2
S Tillamook Salted Butter Spread2
S Vital Farms Unsalted Pasture-Raised Butter1
D Cabot Creamery Unsalted Butter1
D Plugra European Style Salted Butter Tub3
F Country Crock Plant Butter with Avocado Oil11
F EARTH BALANCE Original Buttery Spread10
F Land O'Lakes Land O Lakes Butter with Canola Oil3

Compare two labels side by side

Entries printed on both lines are marked "shared". The text is the ingredient list from the cited source, as parsed by our script.

All products

ProductTierEntriesRuleSource
Challenge Salted ButterS3R3USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Good & Gather Salted ButterS2R3USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Kerrygold Unsalted Butter SticksS3R3USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Organic Valley Organic Salted ButterS2R3USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Tillamook Salted Butter SpreadS2R3USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Vital Farms Unsalted Pasture-Raised ButterS1R3USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Cabot Creamery Unsalted ButterD1R2USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Plugra European Style Salted Butter TubD3R2USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Country Crock Plant Butter with Avocado OilF11R1USDA · Nov 12, 2026
EARTH BALANCE Original Buttery SpreadF10R1USDA · Nov 12, 2026
Land O'Lakes Land O Lakes Butter with Canola OilF3R1USDA · Nov 12, 2026

How tiers are decided

The same rules, in this order, for every product in this guide. The first rule that matches decides the tier.

  1. F R1. The cited line names an oil.
  2. D R2. The cited line names natural flavor or natural flavoring (and no oil).
  3. S R3. The cited line names none of the entries in rules R1 and R2.
Want the verdicts, the label text and the sources for every product?

The PDF guide has them, plus a store checklist.

Buy this guide · $4.99

Our opinion, based on the ingredient lists we cite; the same rules were applied to every product. Lists can be older than the package on the shelf, so always read your own label. Data: USDA FoodData Central.

More tier lists

See all 40 guides